How to Calculate the Real Cost of Offering Group Health Benefits Beyond the Premium

An image of a Dallas woman wearing a suit and holding a cup

Are you feeling overwhelmed by the hidden costs of offering group health benefits to your employees? Do you find yourself wondering, “Is there more to this than just the premium? Why does it feel like the numbers never add up?”

If you’ve been focusing solely on your monthly premium and ignoring the extra expenses that come with health benefits, you’re not alone. Many Dallas business owners and HR managers have been in the same boat. The truth is, there’s a lot more that contributes to the real cost of offering group health benefits costs you may not even realize.

Imagine this: You’re sipping your coffee, casually scrolling through our blog, and in just a few minutes, you’ll have the knowledge to fully understand what’s eating into your budget. No more guessing. No more confusion. By the end of this guide, you’ll know exactly what contributes to the real cost of offering health benefits to your employees and how you can save money while providing the best coverage.

By the end of this blog, you’ll know:

  • The true cost of offering group health insurance beyond just premiums.
  • Hidden expenses like deductibles, copays, and administrative fees.
  • How employee participation and plan design impact costs.
  • The difference between ACA, private, group, and Medicare health plans.

How Wilkerson Insurance Agency can help you navigate these complexities with ease.

What You Need to Know About Group Health Benefits Costs

When most business owners think of group health benefits, they immediately focus on the premium cost. While premiums are a significant part of the picture, they don’t tell the full story.

There are several additional costs to consider, including:

  • Deductibles: The amount your employees need to pay out-of-pocket before insurance kicks in.

  • Copays and Coinsurance: Out-of-pocket costs employees pay for healthcare services.

  • Administrative Fees: Third-party costs, HR systems, and the management of your plan.

  • Employee Participation: Contributions and shared costs between employees and the employer.

Understanding these elements will give you a clearer picture of how group health benefits are affecting your bottom line.

Why Group Health Plans Can Be Costly

Premiums Are Just the Start

Premiums are often the largest visible cost, but they’re only one piece of the puzzle. When calculating the real cost, consider the additional expenses of:

  • Out-of-Pocket Costs: Deductibles and copays can quickly add up if employees need frequent care.

  • Network Restrictions: If employees need out-of-network services, your costs can spike.

  • Administrative Fees: Managing a group health plan requires time and resources, both of which come at a cost.

How Employee Participation Affects the Overall Cost

The level of employee participation in the health plan can significantly impact the overall cost. Businesses that cover a larger portion of the premium typically see higher costs but benefit from better employee satisfaction and retention.

However, sharing the cost with employees through payroll deductions or high-deductible plans can lower the employer’s overall contribution.

The Role of Administrative Fees

Administrative costs are another often-overlooked factor. Managing a health plan, whether in-house or through a third-party administrator (TPA), incurs fees. These might include:

  • Setup costs
  • Ongoing management fees
  • Claims processing

It’s important to factor these into your total cost when evaluating health benefits options.

How to Calculate the True Cost of Health Insurance Plans

Calculating the true cost involves more than just adding up premiums. Here’s a simple framework for understanding the complete financial picture:

Cost Element

What to Look For

Premiums

The basic cost of the health insurance plan.

Out-of-Pocket Costs

Copays, coinsurance, and deductibles.

Employee Participation

Employee contributions towards premiums and care.

Administrative Fees

Costs for managing and administering the plan.

Adding these up will give you a better understanding of what your business is truly paying.

ACA, Private, Group & Medicare Which Covers Mental Health Best?

Understanding the different types of health insurance plans and how they affect your costs is essential. Here’s a breakdown of the most common options:

ACA Marketplace Plans (Dallas)

ACA plans must cover mental health and substance abuse services, but premiums can be higher depending on the plan’s level of coverage.

Private Off-Exchange Plans

Private plans offer more flexibility but may not offer the same comprehensive mental health coverage as ACA plans.

Group Insurance for Small Businesses

Group health plans typically offer a more extensive benefits package, including mental health coverage, at more affordable rates for employees. These are often the best value for businesses.

Medicare & Medicare Supplement Plans

Medicare covers mental health services for seniors, though some services may require additional costs or Medicare Supplement Plans.

How Wilkerson Insurance Agency Can Help You Navigate the Cost of Health Benefits

At Wilkerson Insurance Agency, we’re not just here to help you choose a health plan. We’re your partner in making health benefits work for your business and employees. Here’s how we simplify the process:

We Compare Dozens of Plans for You

We provide a range of options, so you can choose the most affordable and comprehensive coverage for your employees.

We Explain Everything in Simple Language

Health benefits can be confusing. We break down complex terms and provide easy-to-understand explanations.

We Help You Avoid Billing & Network Mistakes

With our experience, we help ensure your employees are using the right network and that you’re not hit with unexpected costs.

We Stay With You Year-Round (Not Just During Enrollment)

Our support doesn’t end at enrollment. We provide ongoing assistance, ensuring that you continue to make the most of your health benefits throughout the year.

Why Choose Wilkerson Insurance Agency

  • Local Dallas Expertise: 15+ years of trusted guidance from a local agency.

     

  • Truly Independent Brokerage: We shop dozens of carriers for the best rates.

     

  • “Family, Not Just a Client” Service: We treat you like family.

     

  • Experienced Team With Healthcare Backgrounds: Our agents have decades of combined insurance and healthcare experience.

     

  • Year-Round Support: Not just during open enrollment.

     

  • Bilingual Service: We serve the diverse Dallas community with clarity and comfort.

     

Service Areas

  • Dallas: Individual & Family Health Insurance Plans
  • Carrollton: Group Health Insurance Plans
  • Coppell: Medicare Supplement Plans
  • Farmers Branch: Dental Insurance Plans
  • Grand Prairie: Vision Insurance Plans
  • Irving: HSA Plans
  • Lewisville: Life Insurance Plans

Group health plans typically include medical, dental, and vision coverage, and often offer mental health benefits as well.

Administrative fees can add significant costs to a group health plan, particularly if you’re using a third-party administrator.

Yes, most group health plans provide coverage for mental health services, though the extent of coverage varies depending on the plan.

Yes, group health plans can often be tailored to meet the specific needs of your employees.

The best way to save is by comparing different plans, understanding all hidden costs, and choosing a plan with the right network and coverage for your team

Conclusion: You Don’t Have to Figure This Out Alone

Understanding the true cost of offering group health benefits can be overwhelming, but with the right help, it doesn’t have to be. At Wilkerson Insurance Agency, we specialize in providing businesses in Dallas with the guidance and support they need to navigate the complexities of health insurance.

Picture of LeRoy Wilkerson

LeRoy Wilkerson

LeRoy Wilkerson is the founder of Wilkerson Insurance Agency, an independent health insurance agency serving the
Dallas - Fort Worth community since 2010. He leads with a simple philosophy: educate first, advocate always. Every client starts with a discovery consultation so LeRoy can understand their goals, budget, and coverage needs, then he helps them
navigate plans and benefits - truly "Taking the Hell out of Health Insurance."

Scroll to Top